NEWS
The Role of Corporate Social Responsibility in Hong Kong

Sodata Analytics Foundation
Colin C.F. Chow

 
Much has been said as of late about the benefits of Corporate Social Responsibility in an international context, particularly in the Western world. Philanthropic and volunteer action, both on a personal and business scale, has promoted mutually beneficial relationships between donators and beneficiaries in American and European countries, amongst others. However, amongst even the largest companies listed on the Hong Kong Stock Exchange, the role of CSR is decidedly lacklustre in comparison to their global competitors; the average donation of a company on the FTSE 100 index is over twice that of one on the Hang Seng Index1. Sodata’s research hopes to address the largely untapped possibilities of social investing in a local context, and in doing so raise further awareness about the links between company sustainability and CSR. As employers, employees, charities and consumers, we ourselves need to understand the importance of societal action within the businesses we interact with in order to truly have an impact on the world around us.
 
Corporate Social Investing is typically defined as actions, not limited to philanthropic or volunteer work, that furthers the good of the society beyond the interests, legal or otherwise, of a firm. The vast majority of reported data on this subject found in company reports is in the form of a monetary value, typically including total donations in legal tender and the value of work hours spent through employee volunteer schemes. The data provided in this report will be in this format simply because it is the only data format that is widely accepted and thus can be used for comparison. However, it must be made clear that works of societal value can come in a wide variety of different formats not limited to those of monetary value, and that all actions to benefit the wider community are certainly considered to be of importance.

 
The importance of transparency in the field of corporate social investing cannot be underestimated. Not only do standard reporting practices help to avoid issues of inconsistent data and misconduct, it is also a vital step to increase public perception and scrutiny of such figures. Out of the 1742 companies included in Sodata’s study, all on the Hong Kong Stock Exchange, only around 55% reported figures for community investment in their annual report, in comparison to 98% of FTSE 100 firms2. Why does this matter? A consumer study in the UK found that over half of the adults questioned would be more willing to purchase a product from a company that donates to charitable causes1. This figure is even higher for those of a younger generation, with nearly two thirds of so-called ‘millennials’ born between 1980 and 2000 being more inclined to use a service from an actively donating firm3. It is therefore clear that, in tandem with effective marketing techniques and increasing public awareness of the field, charitable donations are an effective form of promoting a brand’s individual image, and one that is largely untapped in Asia at the moment.
 


 
With retrospective data of corporate donation statistics from the years 2013 to 2017, it is possible to investigate the year on year change in donation rates and observe any trends. The above graph was compiled from year-on-year data of companies listed on the Hong Kong Stock Exchange with annual revenue above 50 billion Hong Kong Dollars. From the comparison between average revenue invested into social causes and yearly average revenue, it is clear that despite fluctuating fortunes in the stock exchange reflected through unstable revenue, the rate of donation has increased steadily. This consistent upwards trend is undoubtedly encouraging and suggests that companies do not donate solely based on the firm’s financial situation, as expected giving out some money if excess profit available. Rather, these figures suggest that companies are increasingly beginning to appreciate the importance of CSR, allocating a consistent quota of funds to community causes regardless of the year’s revenue. Indeed, with the ever-increasing public perception of community investment in Hong Kong and Mainland China, philanthropic data could be used to advertise the stability, sustainability and continued profitability of a company despite fluctuating revenue, creating an impression of continued dependability towards existing and potential stakeholders.
 
Further analysis was conducted with the 127 companies that had, in 2017, reported a revenue figure of over HKD$50 billion. Splitting the companies into sixteen categories based on industry, some surprising trends can be seen. High-profile firms, particularly those in industries interacting most with the general public as consumers, tend to be more perceived by the public as large donators4, largely due to widespread marketing campaigns. These industries may include financials, technology or consumer goods and services. The below graph takes the median value of each sector of industry and, contrary to public opinion, clearly shows the property sector at the top, with agriculture and financials, both of banking and otherwise, following closely. Indeed, the property sector also boasted the firm with the highest rate of donation in the list of high-revenue companies; Evergrande invested 1.343% of its revenue for community-based causes. However, it should be noted that these figures lag far behind their European or American counterparts. The aforementioned property developer Evergrande was the only company to donate over 0.5% of its revenue to charitable causes out of the 127 high revenue companies, in comparison to 46% of companies in the FTSE 100 index to do so1.
 
  
When assessing the possible motivation behind companies to engage in Corporate Social Responsibility initiatives, however, it appears curious that the property industry, an industry that does not do business directly with final consumers, would come out top in the donation charts. Corporate philanthropy is typically used as a form of brand differentiation to make a firm more appealing to potential customers5. Combining these initiatives with effective marketing and customer engagement, companies can appeal to customers in a different, more ethical manner, giving the firm in question a certain advantage over other competitors in the industry. However, what this model does not take into account is the means by which the company in question may invest in societal good. In terms of cost-benefit analysis, traditional CSR efforts amongst Hong Kong-listed companies vastly overlook the potential for charity action within one’s own field, with the potential for extremely effective philanthropic work at a lower cost to the company. Examination of company annual reports or specific environmental, social and governance reports have revealed that, whilst most companies delineate primarily monetary donations to various non-profit organisations, with a select few describing employee work hours dedicated to helping non-government organisations, the area in which the property industry excels is in direct societal action within the field of the industry. The development of poverty alleviating infrastructure, including villages, schools, agricultural facilities amongst others, is hugely effective and comes within the primary area of expertise for the firms involved. Further benefits to the company can still be reaped after the conclusion of such a project, as poverty decreases and the area in question attracts further investment. Over half of the donation rate of Evergrande Property Development was in this form6, with poverty alleviation schemes underway in seven counties in Mainland China. A second example of this scheme of donating within one’s industry can be seen in the second highest donating sector, agriculture. Mengniu Dairy, contributing over 24 million Hong Kong Dollars to societal action in 2017, has implemented the “Mengniu Inclusion Nutrition Plan”, providing rural schools in 157 Chinese regions and counties with dairy products, as well as projects to introduce breeding and rearing technology to further optimise farm production across the country7. The effectiveness of such ventures appertains to returning to the community whilst opening avenues for future projects and ensuring company sustainability in the years to come.
 
The benefits of Corporate Social Investing are undoubtedly far-reaching, yet they still remain unseen and untapped in the majority of Hong Kong and China-based companies. Far from a mere gesture of kindness, community investment can provide much-needed sustainability, stability and growth in a business, as well as enriching public perception of the corporation whilst benefiting society. As indispensable parts of the economic system, as leaders, employees and consumers, we must all do our part to elevate CSR into the public eye, for our good and for the greater good of society.
 
 
“Corporate Social Giving by the FTSE 100”, CAF, 2014 - 
https://www.cafonline.org/docs/default-source/about-us-publications/corporate_giving_ftse100_august2014.pdf

2Annual and Corporate Reports for the FTSE 100
 
3“Public Perceptions of Social Giving”, CAF, 2014
  
4Ibid.
 
5“Six Reasons Companies Should Embrace CSR”, Forbes, 2012 - 
https://www.forbes.com/sites/csr/2012/02/21/six-reasons-companies-should-embrace-csr/#2c5b5fdc3495
 
 
6 Environmental, Social and Governance Report, China Evergrande Group, 2017 - http://www.hkexnews.hk/listedco/listconews/SEHK/2018/0720/LTN20180720285.pdf

7 Announcement of Annual Results, China Mengniu Dairy Company Ltd, 2017 - http://www.hkexnews.hk/listedco/listconews/SEHK/2018/0327/LTN201803271497.pdf

FOUNDATION

Donations

Copyright